Short answer: Choose disposable covers if you only need them now and then, or you want a fresh pair for every visit, like realtors, cleaners and guests at home. Choose reusable covers if you are in and out of homes or job sites every day and want to stop re-buying. Our reusable pair is machine washable and lasts up to 6 months.
Disposable vs reusable at a glance
| Disposable | Reusable | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | 100-pack $24.99 (50 pairs), 200-pack $39.99 (100 pairs) | $19.99 for 2 pairs |
| Cost per pair | About $0.40 to $0.50 (about $0.34 in the Contractor Case) | About $10, worn many times |
| How long it lasts | One use | Up to 6 months |
| Cleaning | None. Throw them away. | Machine washable |
| Water | Water-resistant, non-slip sole | Waterproof, rubberized non-slip sole |
| Fit | Shoe sizes 6 to 14, men's work boots up to 13 | Stretches to fit up to US men's 13 and all women's sizes |
| Best for | Occasional visits, open houses, guests, a fresh pair every time | Daily use, wet or muddy sites, repeat visits |
Prices as of September 2026.
When disposable covers make sense
- You only need covers a few times a month, or for guests and service visitors.
- You want a fresh pair at every stop, with nothing to wash or store.
- You are hosting an open house or showing several homes in a day.
- You want to hand pairs to other people, such as contractors or cleaners.
When reusable covers make sense
- You are in and out of homes or job sites almost every day.
- You work in wet, muddy or rainy conditions and want a waterproof cover.
- You would rather wash one pair than keep buying boxes.
How many visits before reusable pays off?
At roughly $0.40 to $0.50 per pair for disposables and about $10 per reusable pair, the price breaks even at around 20 to 25 visits per pair. If you will wear the same pair that many times, reusable saves money. Reusable covers do need to be kept clean, so if you move between homes where a fresh start matters, a new disposable pair each time is simpler.
What about the environment?
One reusable pair replaces many disposable ones, so over time it sends less to landfill. Our disposable covers are polypropylene, which can be recycled where local facilities accept it. See what to know about recycling shoe covers and our honest look at the environmental impact.
Can you use both?
Many crews keep a reusable pair for wet or muddy days and use disposable covers inside clients' homes. Our Contractor Case includes a free pair of reusable covers ($19.99 value), so you get both.
Frequently asked questions
How many disposable covers do I need?
One pair per visit. A 100-pack is 50 pairs, so it covers 50 visits.
Can I wash disposable shoe covers?
No. They are designed for single use. If you want covers you can wash, choose reusable ones.
Will reusable covers fit women's shoes?
Yes. Our reusable covers stretch to fit up to US men's size 13 and all women's sizes.
Are disposable covers waterproof?
They are water-resistant, not fully waterproof. Read how we test water resistance.
Ready to choose?
Shop disposable shoe covers, shop reusable covers, or read our buying guide for sizes and colors.